Internet bill undermines free expression

Internet bill undermines free expression
Posted on July 28, 2021 | Stefan Klietsch | Written on July 28, 2021
Letter type:
Blog Post

With the support of the New Democratic Party, the Bloc Quebecois, and the Green Party, the House of Commons passed the Trudeau Liberal government's Bill C-10, An Act to amend the Broadcasting Act.  In simple terms, the bill puts the Internet under the regulatory discretion of the Canadian Radio-television and Telecommunications Council (CRTC).  This bill is laughable, concerning, meandering, ill-conceived, confusing, pointless, and unprecedented all at the same time.

Where to begin?  Bill C-10 sets up CRTC bureaucrats with free discretion to regulate and impose Canadian content restrictions on the Internet, even though the Internet knows no national borders!

What regulations will be imposed on which websites?  Your guess is as good as that of the Liberal government's own guess.  The unelected CRTC will decide for itself how much to apply its powers and where.  Liberals even voted at committee to remove exemptions for user-generated platforms from CRTC oversight, so who knows how your Facebook account will be impacted.  The CRTC will become the ultimate decider.

The sheer unpredictability of Bill C-10 likely accounts for the lack of public outrage to date in response: everyone knows what the problems of the Internet are, no one knows what specific new problems the bill will introduce.  Except that we can be certain that whoever will be affected and when, they will be punished with reduced freedom of expression.  That is the clear warning of Michael Geist, Canada Research Chair in Internet and E-commerce Law at the University of Ottawa, and the advocacy organization OpenMedia; both were previously also outspoken against the prior Conservative government's own careless intrusions into Internet privacy.

Bill C-10 may yet die if a federal election is called before the Senate can potentially pass it.  But whether the bill passes or dies in the Senate, or whether parties campaign for it in a potential upcoming election, one thing is for certain: advocates for net neutrality and free expression online have a fight on their hands, a fight for which the opposing advocates of simple non-solutions will fervently take up.


Stefan Klietsch


About The Author

Stefan Klietsch's picture

Stefan Klietsch grew up in the Ottawa Valley outside the town of Renfrew.  He later studied Political Science at the University of Ottawa, with a Minor in Religious Studies.  He was the 2015 Green Party of Canada... More